Menu engineering: stars, plowhorses, puzzles and dogs
A simple way to see which dishes earn you money, and what to do with the rest.
2 min read
Some dishes sell a lot, some earn a lot, and a few do both. Menu engineering sorts your dishes by two questions: how popular is it, and how much profit does each one make? The answers put every dish in one of four boxes.
Work out two numbers per dish
- Popularity
- How many you sold in a period (say, a month), compared with the average dish in the same section.
- Profit per dish (contribution margin)
- Menu price, minus the cost of its ingredients. Compare it with the average for the section.
The four boxes
- Stars: popular, high profit
- Your best dishes. Keep the quality and the recipe exactly the same, and make them easy to spot on the menu.
- Plowhorses: popular, low profit
- Guests love them, but they earn little. Try a small price rise, a cheaper side, or a slightly smaller portion. Change carefully.
- Puzzles: unpopular, high profit
- They earn well when they sell. Try a better name or description, a better spot on the menu, or ask staff to recommend them.
- Dogs: unpopular, low profit
- Usually best removed, unless they serve a purpose (a children's dish, a vegan option).
Menu design tips
- Fewer dishes are easier to cook well and cost less in waste.
- Guests' eyes go to boxed items and the first and last items in a list. Put stars and puzzles there.
- Write descriptions that make people hungry: where it's from, how it's cooked.
- Leave currency symbols off prices, or keep them small; long rows of prices make people compare by price alone.
Make it easier with Chime Bee
One platform for your entire hospitality business: bookings, front desk, guest requests by QR code, bills, kitchen, housekeeping, staff and stock. Practise free with no time limit and no card, with free setup help.