Menu engineering: stars, plowhorses, puzzles and dogs

A simple way to see which dishes earn you money, and what to do with the rest.

2 min read

Some dishes sell a lot, some earn a lot, and a few do both. Menu engineering sorts your dishes by two questions: how popular is it, and how much profit does each one make? The answers put every dish in one of four boxes.

Work out two numbers per dish

Popularity
How many you sold in a period (say, a month), compared with the average dish in the same section.
Profit per dish (contribution margin)
Menu price, minus the cost of its ingredients. Compare it with the average for the section.

The four boxes

Stars: popular, high profit
Your best dishes. Keep the quality and the recipe exactly the same, and make them easy to spot on the menu.
Plowhorses: popular, low profit
Guests love them, but they earn little. Try a small price rise, a cheaper side, or a slightly smaller portion. Change carefully.
Puzzles: unpopular, high profit
They earn well when they sell. Try a better name or description, a better spot on the menu, or ask staff to recommend them.
Dogs: unpopular, low profit
Usually best removed, unless they serve a purpose (a children's dish, a vegan option).

Menu design tips

  • Fewer dishes are easier to cook well and cost less in waste.
  • Guests' eyes go to boxed items and the first and last items in a list. Put stars and puzzles there.
  • Write descriptions that make people hungry: where it's from, how it's cooked.
  • Leave currency symbols off prices, or keep them small; long rows of prices make people compare by price alone.

Make it easier with Chime Bee

One platform for your entire hospitality business: bookings, front desk, guest requests by QR code, bills, kitchen, housekeeping, staff and stock. Practise free with no time limit and no card, with free setup help.